cbwww/site/gnuboot.md

title	x-toc-enable
Canoeboot vs GNU Boot	true

tl;dr as of 26 October 2023, Canoeboot code is about 1 year ahead of GNU Boot in terms of development, and about 2 years ahead in terms of documentation. Read on, if you want details. GNU Boot is also known as gnuboot. The purpose of Canoeboot is to demonstrate the inferiority of GNU policy, by providing the highest quality releases possible, based on Libreboot, keeping sync with Libreboot while showing what boards/features would have to be removed from Libreboot, if it were to comply with GNU Boot. In other words, Canoeboot is the logical conclusion of what is possible under GNU policy.

Libreboot's Binary Blob Reduction Policy provides an alternative, where users have boot firmware that is as much free software as possible, while not being dogmatic about it. You can learn more by reading that policy.

Canoeboot and GNU Boot are both forks of Libreboot, designed to comply with the GNU Free System Distribution Guidelines. This page is maintained, to show the differences between these two projects.

This current version of the page pertains to Canoeboot 20231026 versus GNU Boot 0.1 RC. You can find GNU Boot ("gnuboot") on the GNU Savannah website.

You can also read the Canoeboot 20231101 changelog; that release only came out 7 days after the 20231026 release, so the rest of this page is more or less accurate, when combined with the facts on the 20231101 announcement.

GNU Boot 0.1 RC based on Libreboot 20220710

This fact is very important; nonGeNUine Boot's 20230717 changelog is relative to Libreboot 20220710, and Canoeboot 20231026's changelog is relative to nonGeNUine Boot 20230717's changelog.

Therefore, this page will analyse differences in both projects, at these two points. First, let's analyse GNU Boot, with the tag reset to 0.1-rc1, which corresponds to commit ID a64d284fd798d843133c9d7274bba17bd7837174. Since GNU Boot also contains the Libreboot history that it forked from, it contains the Libreboot 20220710 release tag, so we can do this:

git log --graph --pretty=format:'%Cred%h%Creset %s %Creset' --abbrev-commit 20220710..0.1-rc1

Within the GNU Boot git repository, this would yield the following response:

* a64d284 .gitignore: order alphabetically 
* 0df4fe5 GRUB: config from HDD/SSD: Add support for gnuboot_grub.cfg 
* ce13d22 GRUB: Use GNU Boot logo 
* 74b678c GRUB: Say the name GNUBoot in the grub menu 
* eeddd2b build/dependencies: debian: adding python-is-python3 to build seabios properly 
* 58b8e09 coreboot/fam15h: don't build ada toolchain for generic platforms 
* f7c0fec coreboot/fam15h: update code base, deblob, unset CONFIG_STM (see bug #64535) 
* de9297f coreboot/fam15h: fix crossgcc acpica build on newer hostcc 
* c38348d coreboot/fam15h: fix for gcc/gnat building 
* 0d77d99 coreboot/fam15h: fixing binutils not building properly 
* b773079 coreboot/default, coreboot/fam15h: use GNU mirror for acpica 
* bf17993 Continue Libreboot under the GNU project

And that's all. The fam15h-related fixed are actually merged from the fsdg20230625 branch of Libreboot, made during July 2023. See: https://browse.libreboot.org/lbmk.git/log/?h=fsdg20230625

The other patches are also merged (cherry-picked) from Libreboot! The above commit log is all that GNU Boot did, for their 0.1 RC1 release.

Therefore, to know the differences between Canoeboot and GNU Boot, I will copy all items first from the nonGeNUine Boot 20230717 change log, and then the Canoeboot 20231026 change log, but I will skip those entries that define features which GNU Boot already has.

On this day, GNU Boot's current commit ID (in the main branch) is 54c6ae497d49c233b654c171978baa77b90ffe17 from 12 October 2023. Most of the changes since 0.1 RC1 up to that commit are just documentation changes, and even still, only cherry-picking minor patches here and there that were already done in Libreboot, in some cases years ago. It's worth noting that the GNU Boot documentation is based on Libreboot documentation from late 2021 or at most, very early 2022.

I don't need to compare documentation, and it would take too long. Their documentation is 2 years out of date, what more is there to say?

Now, feature comparisons in the build systems:

Canoeboot 20231026 features that GNU Boot lacks

Board support

Canoeboot has these boards fully supported, that GNU Boot currently lacks support for:

• Dell Latitude E6400
• ASUS Chromebook Flip C101 (gru-bob)
• Samsung Chromebook Plus (v1) (gru-kevin)

Git revisions in Canoeboot 20231026:

• Coreboot (default): commit ID d862695f5f432b5c78dada5f16c293a4c3f9fce6, 12 October 2023
• Coreboot (fam15h_udimm): commit ID 1c13f8d85c7306213cd525308ee8973e5663a3f8, 16 June 2021
• GRUB: commit ID e58b870ff926415e23fc386af41ff81b2f588763, 3 October 2023
• SeaBIOS: commit ID 1e1da7a963007d03a4e0e9a9e0ff17990bb1608d, 24 August 2023
• U-Boot: commit ID 4459ed60cb1e0562bc5b40405e2b4b9bbf766d57, 2 October 2023

Git revisions in GNU Boot 0.1 RC1:

• Coreboot (default): commit ID b2e8bd83647f664260120fdfc7d07cba694dd89e, 17 November 2021
• Coreboot (fam15h_udimm): commit ID 1c13f8d85c7306213cd525308ee8973e5663a3f8, 16 June 2021
• GRUB: commit ID f7564844f82b57078d601befadc438b5bc1fa01b, 25 October 2021
• SeaBIOS: commit ID 1281e340ad1d90c0cc8e8d902bb34f1871eb48cf, 24 September 2021
• U-Boot: does not exist (no ARM/U-Boot support in Libreboot 20220710) NOTE: GNU Boot does support downloading, deblobbing and re-compressing U-Boot archives, and in fact does a better job of that than Canoeboot in some ways, but it does not yet actually build U-Boot, and it does not boot U-Boot in any way, on any actual mainboards.

As you can see, Canoeboot's revisions are a lot newer.

GRUB LUKS2 support with argon2

Canoeboot 20231026 contains a heavily patched version of GRUB, which contains argon2 support. This allows full decryption of LUKS2 volumes, without having to switch to different key derivation (PBKDF2) and without needing to use LUKS1. You can simply use the default LUKS2 setup provided by any distro, and it will work. More information is available about GRUB cryptomount, in the GNU+Linux guide - search on that page for LUKS2 or argon2.

GNU Boot completely lacks this feature, as of 26 October 2023. It can only support LUKS2 if the key derivation is downgraded to PBKDF2 (insecure, or to LUKS1 (also insecure).

For all intentions, the average user cannot have a fully encrypted system on GNU Boot. They must leave /boot unencrypted on GNU+Linux distros.

With Canoeboot, you can have encrypted /boot very easily. This is a boon for security, because it reduces the chance of someone tampering with your data successfully, and combined with other steps, can be used to reduce the risk of evil maid attacks (by making it infeasible).

GRUB detached LUKS headers

GRUB 2.12 also supports detached LUKS headers, whereas GRUB 2.06 does not. GNU Boot currently uses GRUB 2.06 as its payload. Canoeboot and Libreboot both use GRUB 2.12 as a payload.

Serprog support

Canoeboot can build firmware images for RP2040 and STM32 microcontrollers, using pico-serprog and stm32-vserprog respectively. This can be used to set up an SPI flasher of high quality, but these parts are low-cost.

GNU Boot does not support this feature, as of 26 October 2023.

Simplified command structure

There are 9 shell scripts in Canoeboot 20231026, versus about 50 in GNU Boot 0.1 RC1, because GNU Boot uses the pre-audit design; Libreboot used to have lots of very simple scripts, but ended up with a lot of code repetition.

The new lbmk design generalises all of the logic, doing away with the very hacky logic that existed in the old build system design.

The interface in Canoeboot's build system is much easier to use. For example, the commands are shorter, and easier to remember. See: cbmk maintenance manual tells you everything about the Canoeboot build system.

GNU Boot doesn't even have a maintenance manual, in their version. Their documentation exists in the same repository as code, but their version of docs/maintain/ does not actually contain any instructions, at least as of commit ID a64d284fd798d843133c9d7274bba17bd7837174 on 17 August 2023.

Better documentation

Canoeboot has much better documentation, but this is obvious if you've been paying attention. As already stated: GNU Boot's documentation is horribly out of date, even relative to the version of Libreboot that they're using! (which itself is also horribly out of date)

Canoeboot's build system is smaller

Smaller doesn't mean worse; in fact, Canoeboot's build system is more efficient. It's about 1250 sloc (source lines of code), when counting shell scripts in the core of the build system. Libreboot, Canoeboot and GNU Boot build systems all use the same design, written in shell scripts.

1250 sloc in Canoeboot, versus 2111 in gnuboot; gnuboot however lacks many of the features and improvements that you're about to see below. The Canoeboot build system does several times as many things, in half the amount of code! The code is generally just more reliable, less error prone, and easier to work with, in Canoeboot. GNU Boot uses a very old version of the Libreboot build system design, from long before I started any massive audits. There have been three Libreboot build system audits in 2023, as of 26 October 2023.

Three audits, and Canoeboot has inherited the improvements of all of them. GNU Boot's design is based on the pre-audit lbmk codebase.

Build system / performance improvements in Canoeboot:

• Much stricter, more robust error handling; too many changes to list here, so check the git log. Also, errors that are not errors are no longer treated as such; nonGeNUine Boot 20230717's build system was actually too strict, sometimes.
• Most logic has been unified in single scripts that perform once type of task each, instead of multiple scripts performing the same type of talk; for example, defconfig-based projects now handled with the same scripts, and preparing trees for them is done the same. These unifications have been done carefully and incrementally, with great thought so as to prevent spaghetti. The code is clean, and small.
• GitHub is no longer used on main Git repository links, instead only as backup
• Backup repositories now defined, for all main repos under config/git/
• Single-tree projects are no longer needlessly re-downloaded when they already have been downloaded.
• GRUB LUKS2 support now available, with argon2 key derivation; previously, only PBKDF2 worked so most LUKS2 setups were unbootable in Canoeboot. This is fixed.
• Vastly reduced number of modules in GRUB, keeping only what is required.
• Use --mtime and option options in GNU Tar (if it is actually GNU Tar), when creating Tar archives. This results in partially reproducible source archives, and consistent hashes were seen in testing, but not between distros.
• Always re-inialitise .git within lbmk, for the build system itself, if Git history was removed as in releases. This work around some build systems like coreboot that use Git extensively, and are error-prone without it.
• More robust makefile handling in source trees; if one doesn't exist, error out but also check other makefile name combinations, and only error out if the command was to actually build.
• ROMs build script: support the "all" argument, even when getopt options are used e.g. -k
• Disabled the pager in grub.cfg, because it causes trouble in some non-interactive setups where the user sees an errant message on the screen and has to press enter. This fixes boot interruptions in some cases, allowing normal use of the machine. The pager was initially enabled many years ago, to make use of cat a bit easier in the GRUB shell, but the user can just enable the pager themselves if they really want to.
• U-Boot can now be compiled standalone, without using the ROMs build script, because crossgcc handling is provided for U-Boot now in addition to coreboot.
• All helper scripts are now under include/, and main scripts in script/, called by the main build script
• Generally purge unused variables in shell scripts
• Simplified initialisation of variables in shell scripts, using the setvars function defined under include/err.sh
• Support patch subdirectories, when applying patches. This is done recursively, making it possible to split up patch files into smaller sets inside sub directories, per each source tree (or target of each source tree, where a project is multi-tree within lbmk)
• SPDX license headers now used, almost universally, in all parts of cbmk.
• Files such as those under config/git are now concatenated, traversing recursively through the target directory; files first, then directories in order, and for each directory, follow the same pattern until all files are concatenated. This same logic is also used for patches. This now enables use of subdirectories, in some config/patch directories.
• General code cleanup on util/nvmutil
• Git histories are more thoroughly deleted, in third party source trees during release time.
• Symlinks in release archives are no longer hard copies; the symlinks are re-created by the release script, because it clones the current lbmk work directory via Git (local git clone), rather than just using cp to copy links.
• Properly output to stderr, on printf commands in scripts where it is either a warning prior to calling err, or just something that belongs on the error output (instead of standard output).
• Don't use the -B option in make commands.
• SECURITY: Use sha512sum (not sha1sum) when verifying certain downloads. This reduces the chance for collisions, during checksum verification.
• Set GRUB timout to 5s by default, but allow override and set to 10s or 15s on some mainboards.
• Support both curl and wget, where files are downloaded outside of Git; defer to Wget when Curl fails, and try each program three times before failing. This results in more resilient downloading, on wobbly internet connections.
• Don't clone Git repositories into /tmp, because it might be a tmpfs with little memory available; clone into tmp/gitclone instead, within lbmk, and mv it to avoid unnecessary additional writes (mv is much more efficient than cp, for this purpose).
• Removed unused target.cfg handling in vendor scripts, because they use the concatenated config format instead (they always have).
• Coreboot builds: automatically run make-oldconfig, to mitigate use of raw coreboot config where a revision was updated but the config was untouched. This may still result in a confirmation dialog, and it's still recommended that the configs be updated per revision (or switch them to defconfigs).
• Vastly simplified directory structure; resources/scripts/ is now script/, and resources/ was renamed to config/; ifd and gbe files were also moved to config/ifd/. Commands are now 1-argument instead of 2, for example the ./build boot roms command is now ./build roms.
• memtest86plus: only build it on 64-bit hosts, for now (32-bit building is broken on a lot of distros nowadays, and lbmk doesn't properly handle cross compilation except on coreboot or U-Boot)
• (courtesy of Riku Viitanen) don't use cat on loops that handle lines of text. Instead, use the read command that is built into sh, reading each line. This is more efficient, and provides more robust handling on lines with spaces in them.
• ALL projects now have submodules downloaded at build time, not just multi tree projects such as coreboot - and a few projects under config/git have had certain depend items removed, if a given project already defines it under .gitmodules (within its repository).
• Improved cbutils handling; it's now even less likely to needlessly re-build if it was already built.
• The release build script no longer archives what was already built, but instead builds from scratch, creating an archive from source downloads first before building the ROM archives. This saves time because it enables a single build test per release, whereas at was previously necessary to test the Git repository and then the release archive. Testing both is still desired, but this behaviour also means that whatever is built at release time is guaranteed to be the same as what the user would build (from archives).
• Improved handling of target.cfg files in multi-tree projects coreboot, SeaBIOS and U-Boot. Unified to all such projects, under one script, and with improved error handling.
• GRUB payload: all ROM images now contain the same ELF, with all keymaps inserted. This speeds up the build process, and enables easier configuration when changing the keyboard layout because less re-flashing is needed.
• Simplified IFD handling on ICH9M platforms (e.g. X200/T400 thinkpads); the ich9gen utility wasn't needed anymore so ich9utils has been removed, and now the IFD/GbE files are included pre-assembled (generated by ich9gen). Ich9gen can still be used, or you can re-generate with coreboot's bincfg; the ifdtool util can be used to edit IFD and nvmutil (part of Canoeboot) can change MAC addresses. The ich9utils code was always redundant for the last few years, especially since 2022 when nvmutil was first written.
• Running as root is now forbidden, for most commands; lbmk will exit with non-zero status if you try. The ./build dependencies x commands still work as root (they're the only commands available as root).
• Enabled memtest86plus on more boards, where it wasn't previously enabled.
• Only enable SeaBIOS as first payload on desktops, but still enable GRUB as second payload where GRUB is known to work (on each given host). The text mode and coreboot framebuffer modes are provided in each case, where feasible.
• The list command has been mostly unified, making it easier to tell (from lbmk) what commands are available, without having to manually poke around under script/.
• The -T0 flag is now used, universally, on xz commands. This makes xz run on multiple threads, greatly speeding up the creation of large tar archives.
• Universally use -j in make commands, for multi-threading, but it relies on nproc to get thread count, so this only works if you have nproc (you probably don't, if you run BSD; BSD porting is still on TODO for Canoeboot)
• File names as arguments now universally have quotes wrapped around them, and similar auditing has been done to all variables used as arguments everywhere in lbmk. There were cases where multiple arguments were wrongly quoted then treated as a single argument, and vice versa. This is now fixed.
• Re-wrote .gitcheck; now, a global git name/email config is always required. The only behaviour (setting local config, and unsetting) was quite error-prone under fault conditions, where cleanup may not have been provided, or when execution was interrupted, resulting sometimes in accidentally committing to lbmk.git as author named lbmkplaceholder.
• The new BSD-like coding style is now used on all shell scripts in lbmk. A few scripts still used the old lbmk coding style, as of audit 2.
• Scripts no longer directly exit with non-zero status, under fault conditions; instead, x_ or err is used to provide such behaviour. This results in all exits from lbmk being consolidated to err, under fault conditions. - zero exits are also consolidated, going only through the main script, which has its own exit function called lbmk_exit that provides TMPDIR cleanup.
• BSD-style error handling implemented, with an err function (and functions that use it) inside include/err.sh; there is also x_ which can be used to run a command and exit automatically with non-zero status, useful because it provides more verbose output than if you just relied on set -e, and it still works when a script does not use set -e - however, it is not used on all functions, because it works by executing $@ directly, which can break depending on arguments. Therefore, some scripts just default to || err for providing breakage in scripts.
• Memtest 6.2 now used (instead of 5.x releases). This is essentially a re-write, and it works on the coreboot framebuffer, whereas previous revisions only worked on text mode setups.
• NO MAKEFILE. The Makefile in lbmk has been removed. It was never meaningfully used because all it did was run lbmk commands, without implementing any logic itself. A Makefile may be added again in the future, but with a view to installing just the build system onto the host system, to then build ROM images under any number of directories. Lbmk's design is strictly no-Makefile, but it uses Makefiles provided by third party source trees when building them.
• Safer GRUB configuration file handling between GRUB memdisk and coreboot CBFS; it is no longer possible to boot without a GRUB config, because the one in GRUB memdisk is provided as a failsafe, overridden by inserting one in CBFS, but there is no config in CBFS by default anymore.
• The build system warns users about elf/ vs bin/, when it comes to flashing coreboot ROM images; it tells them to use bin/ because those images do contain payloads, whereas the ones under elf/ do not.
• VASTLY more efficient build process; all coreboot ROMs without payload are now cached under elf/, as are payloads, then they are joined separately by the usual ROMs build script, and these cached ROMs contain many changes in them that were previously handled by moverom in the main ROM build script. Under the new design, repetitive steps are avoided; payloads are inserted into a copy of the cached ROMs under TMPDIR, before being copied for keymaps and small files; this eliminates delays caused by slow compression (LZMA is always used, when inserting payloads). After crossgcc and the payloads are compiled, the ROM with coreboot builds in under a minute, whereas it would have previously taken several minutes on most Canoeboot-supported hardware.
• VASTLY reduced GRUB payload size; modules that aren't needed have been removed resulting in much smaller GRUB payloads, that also boot faster.
• ALL defconfig creation, updating and modification are handled by the same script that also handles compiling, as mentioned in the bullet-point below.
• ALL main source trees are now compiled, downloaded, configured and cleaned using the same script. The download (Git) logic is a separate file under include/ and its functions are called by the main build script, which provides a stub for this.
• Scripts are no longer executed directly, ever, except the main script. All scripts are otherwise executed from script/, inheriting the TMPDIR variable set (and exported) by lbmk.
• Generally improved user feedback in scripts, especially the vendor scripts.
• Coreboot, U-Boot and SeaBIOS are now downloaded, configured and compiled using the exact same script. Although these codebases differ wildly, their build systems use the same design, and they are compatible from a user-interface perspective.
• Vastly improved /tmp handling; a universal TMPDIR is set (environmental variable) and exported to all child processes running lbmk scripts. On exit, the main tmp directory is purged, cleaning all tmp directories under it.
• General simplification of coding style on all shell scripts.
• Fixed some variable initialisations in the coreboot ROM image build script
• Don't enable u-boot on QEMU x86 images (due to buggy builds, untested)
• Fixed coreboot-version file inserted into coreboot trees, when compiled on Canoeboot release archives.
• Very general auditing has been done, finding and fixing bugs.
• Reduced the number of scripts significantly. There were about 50 scripts in the nonGeNUine Boot 20230717 build system. There are closer to 20 in today's Canoeboot 20231026 revision.
• Many scripts that were separate are now unified. For example: the scripts handling defconfigs files on SeaBIOS, u-Boot and coreboot have now been merged into a single script, performing the same work better in less code.
• Ditto many other scripts; repeated logic unified, logic generalised. The logic for downloading coreboot and u-boot was unified into one script, basing off of the coreboot one, and then expanding to also cover SeaBIOS. Most building (e.g. handling of Makefiles) is now done in a single script.
• Far superior error handling; in many scripts, the -e option in sh was heavily relied upon to catch errors, but now errors are handled much more verbosely. Many fault conditions previously did not make lbmk exit at all, let alone with non-zero status, and zero status was sometimes being returned under some edge cases that were tested. Error handling is more robust now.
• util/ich9utils (containing ich9gen) was removed, thus eliminating about 3000 source lines (of C code) from lbmk. The nvmutil program, also provided by and originating from the Canoeboot project, can already change GbE MAC addresses. Coreboot's bincfg can generate ich9m descriptors, and ifdtool can manipulate them; so the features provided by ich9utils were superfluous, since they are available in other projects that we ship. We now ship pre-built ifd/gbe configs on these machines, which can be modified or re-assembled manually if you want to. This eliminates a moving part from Canoeboot, and speeds up the build a little bit.
• ROM images (of coreboot) build much faster: no-payload coreboot ROMs are cached on disk, as are payloads, where previously only the latter was cached. These cached images have as much inserted into them as possible, to eliminate redundant steps in the build process. The elf directory contains these, and the existing bin directory still holds the full ROM images (containing payloads) when compiled.
• GRUB payload: vastly reduced the size of the payload, by eliminating GRUB modules that were not needed. About 100KB of compressed space saved in flash!
• GRUB payload: argon2 key derivation supported - this means LUKS2 decryption is now possible in GRUB. This work was performed by Nicholas Johnson, rebasing from Axel's AUR patch for GRUB 2.06 (Canoeboot currently uses GRUB 2.12).
• The new coding style is now used on many more scripts, including the build/boot/roms_helper script - the new style is much cleaner, mandating that logic be top-down, with a main() function defined; it's basically inspired by the OpenBSD coding style for C programs, adapted to shell scripts.
• All GRUB keymaps now included; a single grub.elf is now used on all ROM images. The grub.cfg goes in GRUB memdisk now, but can be overridden by inserting a grub.cfg in CBFS; many behaviours are also controlled this way, for example to change keymaps and other behaviours. This results in much faster builds, because a different GRUB payload doesn't have to be added to each new ROM image; such takes time, due to time-expensive LZMA compression. This, plus the optimised set of GRUB modules, also makes GRUB itself load much faster. All of the fat has been trimmed, though still quite a lot more than a Crumb.
• A lot of scripts have been removed entirely, and their logic not replaced; in many cases, Canoeboot's build system contained logic that had gone unused for many years.
• More reliable configs now used on desktop mainboards: SeaBIOS-only for start, but GRUB still available where feasible (in the SeaBIOS menu). This makes it more fool proof for a user who might use integrated graphics and then switch to a graphics card; the very same images will work.
• TMPDIR environmental variable now set, and exported from main parent process when running lbmk; child processes inherit it, and a single tmp dir is used. This is then automatically cleaned, upon exit from lbmk; previously, lbmk did not cleanly handle /tmp at all, but now it's pretty reliable.
• A HUGE build system audit inherited from Libreboot, is part of the Canoeboot tree; the entire build system was re-written in a much cleaner coding style, with much stricter error handling and clear separation of logic. A lot of bugs were fixed. A LOT of bugs. Build system auditing has been the main focus, in these past 12 months.
• cros: Disable coreboot-related BL31 features. This fixes poweroff on gru chromebooks. Patch courtesy of Alper Nebi Yasak.
• u-boot: Increase EFI variable buffer size. This fixes an error where Debian's signed shim allocates too many EFI variables to fit in the space provided, breaking the boot process in Debian. Patch courtesy Alper Nebi Yasak
• Coreboot build system: don't warn about no-payload configuration. nonGeNUine Boot compiles ROM images without using coreboot's payload support, instead it builds most payloads by itself and inserts them (via cbfstool) afterwards. This is more flexible, allowing greater configuration; even U-Boot is handled this way, though U-Boot at least still uses coreboot's crossgcc toolchain collection to compile it. Patch courtesy Nicholas Chin.
• util/spkmodem-recv: New utility, forked from GNU's implementation, then re-written to use OpenBSD style(9) programming style instead of the originally used GNU programming style, and it is uses OpenBSD pledge() when compiled on OpenBSD. Generally much cleaner coding style, with better error handling than the original GNU version (it is forked from coreboot, who forked it from GNU GRUB, with few changes made). This is a receiving client for spkmodem, which is a method coreboot provides to get a serial console via pulses on the PC speaker.
• download/coreboot: Run extra.sh directly from given coreboot tree. Unused by any boards, but could allow expanding upon patching capabilities in lbmk for specific mainboards, e.g. apply coreboot gerrit patches in a specific order that is not easy to otherwise guarantee in more generalised logic of the nonGeNUine Boot build system.
• util/e6400-flash-unlock: New utility, that disables flashing protections on Dell's own BIOS firmware, for Dell Latitude E6400. This enables nonGeNUine Boot installation without disassembling the machine (external flashing equipment is not required). Courtesy Nicholas Chin.
• Build dependencies scripts updated for more modern distros. As of this day's release, nonGeNUine Boot compiles perfectly in bleeding edge distros e.g. Arch Linux, whereas the previous 20220710 required using old distros e.g. Debian 10.
• cbutils: New concept, which implements: build coreboot utilities like cbfstool and include the binaries in a directory inside lbmk, to be re-used. Previously, they would be compiled in-place within the coreboot build system, often re-compiled needlessly, and the checks for whether a given util are needed were very ad-hoc: now these checks are much more robust. Very centralised approach, per coreboot tree, rather than selectively compiling specific coreboot utilities, and makes the build system logic in nonGeNUine Boot much cleaner.
• GRUB config: 30s timeout by default, which is friendlier on some desktops that have delayed keyboard input in GRUB.
• ICH9M/GM45 laptops: 256MB VRAM by default, instead of 352MB. This fixes certain performance issues, for some people, as 352MB can be very unstable.
• U-Boot patches: for gru_bob and gru_kevin chromebooks, U-Boot is used instead of Google's own depthcharge bootloader. It has been heavily modified to avoid certain initialisation that is replaced by coreboot, in such a way that U-Boot is mainly used as a bootloader providing UEFI for compliant GNU+Linux distros and BSDs. Courtesy Alper Nebi Yasak.
• lbmk: The entire nonGeNUine Boot build system has, for the most part, been made portable; a lot of scripts now work perfectly, on POSIX-only implementations of sh (though, many dependencies still use GNU extensions, such as GNU Make, so this portability is not directly useful yet, but a stepping stone. nonGeNUine Boot eventually wants to be buildable on non-GNU, non-GNU/Linux systems, e.g. BSD systems)
• nvmutil: Lots of improvements to code quality, features, error handling. This utility was originally its own project, started by Leah Rowe, and later imported into the nonGeNUine Boot build system.
• build/boot/roms: Support cross-compiling coreboot toolchains for ARM platforms, in addition to regular x86 that was already supported. This is used for compiling U-boot as a payload, on mainboards.
• U-boot integration: at first, it was just downloading U-Boot. Board integration for ARM platforms (from coreboot) came later, e.g. ASUS Chromebook Flip C101 as mentioned above. The logic for this is forked largely from the handling of coreboot, because the interface for dealing with their build systems is largely similar, and they are largely similar projects. Courtesy Denis Carikli and Alper Nebi Yasak.
• New utility: nvmutil - can randomise the MAC address on Intel GbE NICs, for systems that use an Intel Flash Descriptor
• General build system fixes: better (and stricter) error handling
• Fixed race condition when building SeaBIOS in some setups.
• GRUB configs: only scan ATA, AHCI or both, depending on config per board. This mitigates performance issues in GRUB on certain mainboards, when scanning for grub.cfg files on the HDD/SSD.
• GRUB configs: speed optimisations by avoiding slow device enumeration in GRUB.

Summary

So, in conclusion: this page is not trying to tell you why you should use Canoeboot; rather, it's just telling you that someone worse exists. Canoeboot and GNU Boot are both inherently flawed in their designs; both projects are completely inferior to the Libreboot project, for all the reasons laid out in the Binary Blob Reduction Policy - the Canoeboot project is provided, specifically, to prove the merits of that policy, by showing what Libreboot would have been by now if it continued adhering to GNU policy, instead of changing to its current Blob Reduction Policy.

Libreboot provides all of the same blob-free configurations as Canoeboot, when possible on any given mainboard, and that is the preference, but the FSF/GNU dogma states that the user must never run any proprietary software. This dogma is wrong; a more correct approach is to say that proprietary software is bad, because it restricts the user's freedom to study and modify the software; it removes their power to say no when the developer wants to change the program in a bad way, it leaves them at the mercy of that developer - the point is this:

Free software is good, and we should be promoting as much of it as possible. This means that a hardline no-blob approach like the policy implemented by Canoeboot (or GNU Boot for that matter), is entirely misguided, because it will only alienate those who just want some free software. Most people like the idea of software freedom but cannot go all the way yet; we should encourage people to make the right choices, but otherwise just help them in whatever way we can, meeting people where they're at right now.

And that is why Libreboot exists in the way that it does. Canoeboot serves as an example of what would happen in the best-case scenario if Libreboot never changed its policy. The best possible release of Canoeboot will still be missing a ton of boards and features from Libreboot. Indeed, the Canoeboot 20231026 and nonGeNUine Boot 20230717 both illustrate that quite nicely.

GNU Boot 0.1 RC3 and Canoeboot 20240102

Dubbed Canoeboot 20240102, though it's not actually a release. For context, first read: https://libreboot.org/news/audit4.html

Canoeboot imported these changes, in revision 102ce12cea023783729d6a2cd1576afc95bf7540 on 2 January 2024. This revision is referred to unofficially as Canoeboot 20240102.

These changes add the following noteworthy improvements, that benefit Canoeboot users:

• GRUB 2.12 stable release, instead of GRUB 2.12-rc1. The stable release came out on 20 December 2023.
• Generic cmake and autoconf handling now, in the build scripts. This means that many more projects can be added more easily to the build system (utilities and such)
• Higher default drive level of 12mA, instead of 4mA, when building serprog images for RP2040-based MCUs
• Generic fixes in the build system, better error checking; failed Git patching now actually exits, whereas in previous releases (and also in GNU Boot's build system, because it inherits Libreboot which had this bug for years), in many older releases, git am failing does not cause the build system to exit. The build continues, erroneously. Libreboot fixed this in audit 4, and Canoeboot has imported this.
• Crossgcc tarballs no longer bundled in releases, making them smaller. The build system still downloads these at build time, but this means that now you will only download what you need, when you build Canoeboot for a board.
• Single-tree projects are now configurable with target.cfg files. This could enable use of crossgcc, if you set xarch, and make/cmake/autoconf arguments are now all configurable in target.cfg - previously, this file was only possible for multi-tree projects.
• grub.cfg: the default config scanning now also searches for syslinux configs, in addition to extlinux, though it still looks for GRUB configs first. GRUB can parse syslinux/extlinux configuration files. Canoeboot's GRUB is also now configured to search for configs on the ESP (EFI System Partition), both on USB media and on the installed system. With these changes, Canoeboot now boots distros much more reliably, especially UEFI-based ones, even though UEFI is not implemented in Caneoboot on x86 yet.

These and other/subsequent changes will be merged with the lists above, when the next Canoeboot release comes out. The main lists of changes above are for the current binary release of Canoeboot, versus GNU Boot.

GNU Boot 0.1 RC3

The article above compares Canoeboot 20231107 and GNU Boot 0.1 RC1. It should be noted that 0.1 RC3 is now available, but it doesn't really add any major changes, and most of the changes are documentation changes. Here is a brief list of changes that would be beneficial to users:

• Removed a few binary blobs that GNU Boot overlooked, which were included in the GNU Boot (these were also overlooked in Canoeboot releases, and have been handled in Canoeboot, thanks to reports sent by Denis Carikli of GNUBoot)
• The CONFIG_USE_BLOBS setting was disabled on all coreboot configs - it is an extra setting that reduces the chance of the coreboot build system accidentally downloading blobs.
• Uses the coreboot build system to generate TOP SWAP bootblocks on i945, rather than using dd. This means that the 2nd bootblock is present in CBFS, reducing the chance that it will be overwritten at build time.
• They've started integrating the Guix package manager into their build system, for example they now use Guix (not to be confused with Guix System, which ironically cannot build GNU Boot due to lack of GCC-Gnat) to build GRUB. This results in higher maintenance burden and slows down development of GNU Boot - I considered using Nix in lbmk, but I need to be able to change everything quickly. Extra complexity like that is overkill. The benefit though is that users can more easily build the software, without thinking about it as much.

GNU Boot 0.1 RC has not altered the coreboot code on any machines, nor the GRUB code, and in fact it seems to be vanilla GRUB 2.06. Most of the changes by 0.1 RC3 have been further integration of the Untitled Static Site Generator maintained by Leah Rowe, adapting Untitled (which builds the Libreboot, Canoeboot and GNU Boot websites) so that it can be used with the GNU Savannah infrastructure more easily (as of 2 January 2024, the GNU Boot project is considering adapting the website for use with Haunt instead of Untitled).

GNU Boot's code complexity increased, considerably. Counting build scripts, the GNU Boot build system is 3216 lines of code, as of 0.1 RC3 - whereas, the Canoeboot 20240102 build system is 1127 lines of code. That's about 3x smaller, but don't let size fool you. Canoeboot's design is highly efficient. It does a lot more than GNU Boot currently does. You'll note that this figure of 1127 is lower than the one given for Canoeboot version 20231107, above. That is because Canoeboot became more efficient since then!

Despite the considerable reduction in code size, by comparison, the Canoeboot build system is much more powerful. It does a lot more, patching and building a lot more projects, including U-Boot, and it handles cross compilation too, for ARM - it also integrates Serprog firmware projects, for STM32 and RP2040 devices, and has much better support for autoconf/cmake-based projects.

The Canoeboot build system is so vastly efficient due to its design. GNU Boot is based upon and expanded from Libreboot 20220710, which used a much more complicated build system design. The Canoeboot build system inherits changes from Libreboot Build System Audit 1, 2, 3 and 4, the purpose of which was (and is) to reduce build system complexity, improving efficiency and reliability, while adding many more features. Essentially, Canoeboot generalises a lot more logic, handling codebases (download, patch, configure, compile) more generically with a single script, whereas GNU Boot has separate scripts for each project, and thus duplicates a lot of logic. While the latter design of GNU Boot is more flexible in some ways, it does result in much higher complexity.

It should be noted that GNUBoot's code complexity increased a lot, relative to Libreboot 20220710 which it forked, while not actually adding any new functionality (none that will be beneficial to most users). The 20220710 build system was 2117 lines of code, versus GNU Boot's 3216, Canoeboot's 1127 and Libreboot's (on 2 January 2024) 1562!

That's all. The information above, and more, will be properly merged into this page when the next release of Canoeboot comes out, or when/if GNU Boot makes considerable technical improvements to their project.

As of 2 January 2024, GNU Boot is still about 1 year behind on code and about 2 years behind on documentation, when comparing to the technical progress of Libreboot; the same numbers also apply to Canoeboot vs GNU Boot.

Canoeboot 20240504

See: Canoeboot 20240504 release.

On this day, 4 May 2024, GNU Boot still has not made much progress; they're still stuck on 0.1 RC3, without my fixes that I showed off in Canoeboot 0.1, that I sent to them;

Now I have Canoeboot 20240504, which is vastly more up to date than the November 2023 Canoeboot release, based on the newest Libreboot 20240504 release (simultaneous release!)

Look at the changelog in that release announcement, and you will see many further changes that Canoeboot has made. GNU Boot is essentially now a pointless project, more so than before; Canoeboot is so far ahead that the only feasible way GNU Boot could survive is to delete itself and start over, by forking from the current revisions of Canoeboot.

But why would they do that? Canoeboot is already FSDG compliant, and provides exactly what they want. But I'm maintaining it, and will continue to do so, so why should anyone want to use their project?